It's strange to think of Sun Microsystems without Scott McNealy at the
helm. I'd been hearing rumors for weeks, which turned into a
confirmation on Friday from someone well connected in the Valley.
Scott was a great CEO once upon a time, probably the best I've ever
had. He cared about the company, and about its employees, in an era
when terms like Human Resources are used to equate workers to raw
materials that can be replaced or junked as needed. He also knew how
and when to reinvent the company, as well as how to get us all behind
the concept du jour. Sun wasn't without its problems, even in its
heydey. (Way too much managing up going on for my taste.) But it was
a good place to work and a force for creativity in an industry that
needs as many of those as it can find.
Not that Scott was always right. I lived through the planetization,
when he had the brilliant idea to break everything up into
self-contained and autonomous business units. Most of those units
failed miserably, and even the ones that didn't spent foolishly, on
advertising (with three or more full page ads from different units in
the same magazine), on packaging (the box for Sun's development tools
cost more than PC vendors charge for their product!) and on trade
shows, were so focused on their own success they ignored what was
right for the company. More recently (and long after I was gone,
thank god) were flex-offices; instead of assigning an office to
employees, you would show up and check a terminal for an available
space. I knew I was right about how bad an idea this was when I heard
several directors talk about how glad they were it didn't apply to
them.
But still, brain farts and all, Scott made Sun the cool and creative
place it was. That he couldn't get it through its latest troubles
shouldn't take away from his accomplishments; maybe no one could have
done better. I don't envy Jonathan Schwartz as the new CEO.